"Obama's Strengths Are His Weaknesses," column by Daniel O'Rourke

| Submitted by admin on September 11, 2009 - 9:47pm.

The following, Obama's Strengths Are His Weaknesses was written by CPJ member Daniel O'Rourke.  It was published in Dan's regular column in the Dunkirk Observer on September 10, 2009. 

 

This column is about President Barack Obama, but I want to start by talking about all of us.  The psychological cliché, “Our strengths are our weakness” is true for everyone.  Our personality traits are a continuum running from one extreme to the opposite extreme. If we are passionately committed to gardening, for example, then we will grow extremely impatient when a fungus rots the tomatoes.  The passion and impatience are the extremes of the same personality trait; they are two sides of the coin.
If you think about it, there are many such examples. If we are decisive getting things done, we must be careful that we are not impulsive.  Confidence can become arrogance. Tenacity can turn into stubbornness. Our loving care to help a child can lead to enabling -- so the child is less able to help himself.  You get the idea.  The positive aspects of our personalities can too easily morph into negative characteristics.
Now let’s take a look at our President.  Some may disagree, but here are his strengths. He is intelligent.  He is calm.  He is friendly.  He sees all sides of issues and is therefore inclined to listen and negotiate.  He is agreeable, i.e. not mean-spirited.  Also -- and admittedly this is more a factor of birth than a personality trait -- he is African American.  All of these helped elect him president with substantial majorities in both the popular and electoral vote.
As I write this column, however, President Obama’s poll numbers are slipping. His honeymoon is over. The multi-headed economic and military monster he inherited has ambushed him -- and the country.  Americans want quick solutions and have grown impatient.  Simultaneously Obama is confronting a number of major crises. I won’t even address nuclear arms negotiations with Russia, cap and trade and global warming, Iran and Israel, or the rising unemployment rate; I only want to mention two crises. The first in passing, whether or not to increase the number of troops in the increasingly unpopular Afghanistan war -- a war whose win-ability is being questioned publicly even by senior Democrats and the President’s advisors. But I’m going to focus on the second: whether or not the President should dramatically shape the floundering health reform effort and push strongly for some sort of public option.

By the time you read this, the President will already have addressed a joint session of Congress.  His willingness to negotiate and compromise with Senate Republicans has backfired.  The Republicans see the issue as a way to bring him down politically. Senator Jim DeMint (R, South Carolina) said it; “If we are able to stop Obama on this it will be his Waterloo.  It will break him.”

Obama’s ability to compromise, his openness to the ideas of others and genuine desire for bipartisanship on health care has boomeranged.  These characteristics have morphed into weakness.  He now appears to many as vacillating, unsure of what he wants or what he will settle for in the bill, yet unwritten, that eventually will reach his desk.  His openness has transmuted into indecisiveness. Perhaps last evening’s historic speech to a joint session of Congress will have changed this.  We will see.


The Lewin Group, a research-consulting firm owned by United Health Group, and widely parroted by the Republicans congressional leadership has orchestrated an effective misinformation campaign with outlandish claims that have lead to fear and hysteria.  They say health care reform would establish death panels for the elderly, drastically reduce your Medicare benefits, and ration the medical procedures for which you are eligible.  (AARP by the way disagrees.)  The health insurance industry, with billions in profits at stake, has marketed their lies with bumper sticker clarity.  No Death Panels!  Obama Lies, Grandma Dies! No Socialized Medicine! No Health Care for Illegal Immigrants!

Up to now Obama’s attempts to refute these distortions have been ineffective. He has addressed them intelligently but academically with detail and nuance.  His intellectual ability, however, has not worked. He has come over as lecturing, boring and pedantic.  His intelligence has become a weakness. Perhaps last night’s speech to Congress will have proved me wrong.

I readily admit that sometimes the President has put his own spin on the budget numbers and many question whether his proposals will produce as much savings as he states.  For many his numbers just do not compute.

Of course, there should be a debate on health care, but it should be civil and honest.  There are key questions of cost, malpractice and the extent of government involvement. The various options should be weighed and argued.  That has not happened.  Instead we have outlandish claims and name-calling epithets.  (Do any thoughtful citizens really think that our President is another Adolph Hitler?)

On his every initiative, the President faces such outlandish slander. His talk to schoolchildren is a telling example. In these insults I smell the stench of racism. A small percentage of Americans just cannot accept that we have elected an African American President -- and they oppose his every step.  Like Rush Limbaugh they do not want him to succeed.  They have created an atmosphere of hate in the country.  We can only pray it does not lead to violence.

Speaking of prayer – and violence, the Rev. Steven Anderson, Pastor of the Faithful Word Baptist Church in Phoenix, Arizona says he prays for President Obama’s death! He prays that the President will die of brain cancer like Ted Kennedy. Anderson says he is against violence, but one of his parishioners after hearing his sermon brought a semi-automatic rifle to a rally in Phoenix where Obama was addressing the Veterans of Foreign Wars.  That was not the first time right wing extremists have brought guns to events when Obama was speaking.

We too should pray for our President, but unlike Pastor Anderson, we should pray that God will shield him from the fanatics, from the Birthers and the Deathers who cannot accept an African American as President of these United States. 

Dan O’Rourke lives in Cassadaga, NY. His column appears in the Observer, Dunkirk, NY on the second and fourth Thursday each month. A grandfather, Dan is a married Catholic priest. He has published "The Spirit at Your Back," a book of previous columns. To read about the book or send comments on this column visit his website http://www.danielcorourke.com/